Skip to main content
How to Appeal a VA Disability Claim Denial: Complete Guide to Winning Your Appeal (2025) - VetClaims.ai VA Pay Calculator and Veteran Benefits Calculator
22 min read
By VetClaims.ai Team

How to Appeal a VA Disability Claim Denial: Complete Guide to Winning Your Appeal (2025)

VA appealclaim deniedsupplemental claimhigher-level reviewboard appealVA decision reviewveterans benefits

Receiving a VA disability claim denial is frustrating—but it's far from the end of the road. Approximately 70% of initial VA claims are denied or rated lower than expected, yet over 50% of appeals succeed when veterans submit proper evidence and choose the right appeal pathway.

If your VA claim was denied or you received a lower rating than you believe you deserve, this comprehensive guide will show you exactly how to appeal, which option to choose, and how to maximize your chances of success. Understanding the appeals process could mean the difference between $0/month and thousands of dollars in monthly compensation.

Understanding Why VA Claims Get Denied

Before jumping into appeals, understanding common denial reasons helps you address the root cause.

Top 10 Reasons VA Claims Are Denied

1. Insufficient Medical Evidence

  • Most common reason (40%+ of denials)
  • No current diagnosis documented
  • Outdated medical records
  • Missing treatment history

2. Lack of Service Connection

  • Can't prove disability occurred in or was caused by service
  • Missing service treatment records (STRs)
  • No buddy statements or evidence placing you in service at time of injury

3. Missing or Weak Nexus (For Secondary Conditions)

  • No medical opinion linking primary to secondary condition
  • Weak nexus language ("may be related" vs. "at least as likely as not")
  • Insufficient explanation of connection

4. Disability Not Severe Enough (0% Rating)

  • VA acknowledges condition exists but rates it 0%
  • Symptoms don't meet rating criteria severity
  • Conflicting medical evidence about severity

5. Claimed Condition Not Currently Diagnosed

  • Symptoms present but no formal diagnosis
  • Diagnosis was in past but condition resolved
  • Need current medical evidence

6. C&P Exam Opinion Outweighs Your Evidence

  • Examiner's opinion contradicts your private medical records
  • Examiner didn't review all evidence
  • Inadequate C&P examination

7. Claimed Too Late (Missing Deadlines)

  • Didn't file Intent to File
  • Missed supplemental claim deadline
  • Didn't appeal within 1 year

8. Pre-Existing Condition (Not Service-Connected)

  • Condition existed before service
  • Can't prove aggravation during service
  • Genetic or constitutional conditions

9. Administrative Errors

  • VA lost evidence
  • Wrong condition evaluated
  • Calculation errors

10. Lack of Lay Evidence

  • No buddy statements
  • No personal statement
  • Missing contemporaneous evidence

Key Insight: Most denials are due to insufficient evidence, not because you don't deserve benefits. The solution is often gathering better documentation and resubmitting through the right appeal pathway.

The New Appeals System: Three Pathways

In 2019, the VA implemented the Appeals Modernization Act (AMA), creating three distinct review options.

Quick Comparison of Appeal Options

FactorSupplemental ClaimHigher-Level ReviewBoard Appeal
New EvidenceRequiredNot allowedOptional (with hearing)
Who ReviewsSame office (DRO)Senior reviewerBoard of Veterans' Appeals
Average Timeline4-6 months4-6 months12-36 months
Hearing OptionNoNoYes (optional)
Success Rate~40%~15%~30-40%
Best ForNew evidence availableClear VA error, no new evidenceComplex cases, need hearing
Can SwitchYes (to HLR or Board)Yes (to Board after)No (final)

Decision Tree: Which Appeal Option Should You Choose?

START: VA denied your claim or gave lower rating than expected
  ↓
Do you have NEW evidence that wasn't in your original claim?
  ↓
  YES → Can you get it quickly (within 1 year)?
    ↓
    YES → Choose SUPPLEMENTAL CLAIM
          - Fastest path with new evidence
          - Can add medical records, nexus letters, buddy statements
          - Restores original effective date if successful
    ↓
    NO (will take >1 year to gather) → File Intent to File for Supplemental Claim
        - Reserves effective date
        - Gives you 1 year to gather evidence
        - Then file Supplemental Claim
  ↓
  NO (no new evidence) → Did the VA make a clear error in the decision?
    ↓
    YES → What kind of error?
      ↓
      Calculation error, wrong law applied, didn't consider evidence →
        Choose HIGHER-LEVEL REVIEW
        - Senior reviewer catches errors
        - No new evidence needed
        - Faster than Board
      ↓
      Complex interpretation, need to explain case in person →
        Choose BOARD APPEAL with hearing
        - Present your case to judge
        - Can submit evidence with hearing
        - Longer timeline but thorough review
    ↓
    NO (no clear error, just disagree) → Do you have time to wait?
      ↓
      YES → BOARD APPEAL with hearing
            - Most thorough review
            - Can present case in person
            - Final decision (can't appeal further to VA)
      ↓
      NO → Gather new evidence and file SUPPLEMENTAL CLAIM

Option 1: Supplemental Claim (Most Common)

A Supplemental Claim allows you to submit new and relevant evidence and have your claim reviewed again.

When to Choose Supplemental Claim

You have new medical evidence

  • Recent diagnosis you didn't have before
  • New treatment records showing severity
  • Medical records VA didn't consider
  • Updated nexus letter for secondary conditions

You can obtain new evidence quickly

  • Private medical exam scheduled
  • Nexus letter in progress
  • Buddy statements being prepared
  • Service treatment records recently obtained

You want fastest resolution

  • Average 4-6 months
  • Can be faster with Fully Developed Claim
  • Much quicker than Board (12-36 months)

Original effective date is valuable

  • Successful supplemental claim restores original effective date
  • Maximizes back pay
  • Worth thousands in retroactive payments

What Qualifies as "New and Relevant" Evidence

New Evidence Includes:

  • Medical records dated after your last decision
  • Nexus letters from doctors (if not previously submitted)
  • Buddy statements (if not in original claim)
  • Service treatment records (STRs) you recently obtained
  • Recent diagnosis or updated diagnosis
  • VA medical records from after decision date
  • New DBQ (Disability Benefits Questionnaire)

Relevant Evidence:

  • Directly relates to the denied condition
  • Addresses the reason for denial
  • Supports service connection or severity

NOT Considered New:

  • Evidence VA already reviewed
  • Repeating same arguments without new documentation
  • Opinion letters without new medical facts

Critical Rule: You must submit new evidence that wasn't part of your original claim. Simply resubmitting the same evidence won't work—it will be denied again.

How to File a Supplemental Claim

Step 1: Request Your C-File

  • Complete VA Form 20-10206
  • Get your entire claims file
  • Review what VA had when they denied your claim
  • Identify what's missing

Step 2: Identify Why You Were Denied

  • Read decision letter carefully
  • Note specific reasons for denial
  • Understand what evidence VA says is missing
  • Target your new evidence to address these gaps

Step 3: Gather New Evidence

Medical Evidence:

  • See doctor for current diagnosis (if lacking)
  • Request all recent medical records
  • Get DBQ completed by provider
  • Obtain nexus letter (for secondary conditions)

Lay Evidence:

  • Write detailed personal statement
  • Collect buddy statements from those who witnessed your condition
  • Gather employment records if TDIU claim
  • Compile photographs/videos showing functional limitations

Service Connection Evidence:

  • Service treatment records (from NPRC)
  • Unit rosters/deployment records
  • Buddy statements from fellow service members
  • Personnel records showing MOS/duties

Step 4: Complete VA Form 20-0995

  • Supplemental Claim Application
  • List new evidence you're submitting
  • Check "Fully Developed Claim" if all evidence ready (faster processing)
  • Can file online at VA.gov or mail

Step 5: Submit All Evidence

  • Upload all documents to VA.gov, OR
  • Mail with Form 20-0995 to regional office
  • Keep copies of everything
  • Request confirmation of receipt

Step 6: Monitor Claim Status

  • Check VA.gov regularly
  • Respond to any VA requests within 30 days
  • Prepare for potential new C&P exam
  • Track processing timeline

Supplemental Claim Timeline

Average Processing:

  • 4-6 months from submission to decision
  • 3-4 months if filed as Fully Developed Claim
  • Can be longer if new C&P exam needed

Expedited Processing Available If:

  • Financial hardship
  • Terminal illness
  • Age 85 or older
  • Medal of Honor recipient
  • Former POW
  • Homeless veteran

Option 2: Higher-Level Review (For VA Errors)

A Higher-Level Review has a senior reviewer re-examine your claim for errors—using only the evidence already in your file.

When to Choose Higher-Level Review

VA made a clear error

  • Applied wrong law or regulation
  • Calculation error (bilateral factor, combined rating)
  • Didn't consider evidence you submitted
  • Misinterpreted medical evidence

No new evidence needed

  • Everything necessary was in original claim
  • VA just didn't review it properly
  • Error is obvious from existing record

You want fast decision

  • Average 4-6 months (similar to supplemental)
  • No waiting for new C&P exam
  • Streamlined process

You disagree with C&P exam conclusions

  • Your medical records clearly contradict C&P examiner
  • C&P examiner didn't review all evidence
  • Inadequate examination (too brief, wrong tests)

Common VA Errors Caught by Higher-Level Review

1. Calculation Errors

  • Combined rating calculated wrong
  • Bilateral factor not applied
  • SMC not calculated correctly
  • Dependent additions missed

2. Evidence Not Considered

  • Medical records submitted but not reviewed
  • Nexus letter ignored
  • Buddy statements overlooked
  • DBQ not considered

3. Wrong Regulation Applied

  • Incorrect diagnostic code used
  • Wrong rating criteria applied
  • Outdated regulation used

4. C&P Exam Issues

  • Examiner didn't review file before exam
  • Inadequate examination performed
  • Opinion contradicts all other evidence
  • Examiner not qualified

5. Service Connection Errors

  • Clear STR showing injury but denied
  • Obvious combat connection ignored (Purple Heart, etc.)
  • Secondary connection not recognized

How to File a Higher-Level Review

Step 1: Identify the Error

  • Review your decision letter
  • Compare to your submitted evidence
  • Note what VA overlooked or miscalculated
  • Use VA Disability Calculator to verify combined rating calculation

Step 2: Complete VA Form 20-0996

  • Higher-Level Review Application
  • Describe the error specifically
  • Reference evidence in your file
  • Note if you want informal conference call

Step 3: Request Informal Conference (Optional but Recommended)

  • 15-30 minute phone call with senior reviewer
  • Explain the error verbally
  • Point reviewer to specific evidence
  • Highly recommended—improves success rate

Step 4: Submit Form

  • File online at VA.gov (fastest)
  • Or mail to VA regional office
  • Within 1 year of decision date
  • No new evidence can be added

Step 5: Prepare for Informal Conference

  • Have your file organized
  • Reference specific pages/documents
  • Be concise and clear about error
  • Focus on facts, not emotions

Higher-Level Review Timeline

Average Processing:

  • 4-6 months from submission to decision
  • Informal conference scheduled within 1-2 months
  • Decision typically 2-4 months after conference

Success Rate:

  • ~15% overall
  • Higher if clear calculation/administrative error
  • Lower if disputing medical judgment

Strategy Tip: If the Higher-Level Review denies your claim again, you can then file a Supplemental Claim with new evidence you gathered in the meantime—essentially combining both approaches sequentially.

Option 3: Board of Veterans' Appeals

A Board Appeal has a Veterans Law Judge at the Board of Veterans' Appeals review your case.

When to Choose Board Appeal

Complex legal interpretation needed

  • Nuanced service connection question
  • Unusual circumstances
  • Precedent-setting case

You want to present your case in person

  • Hearing with judge available
  • Can explain situation verbally
  • Submit additional evidence at hearing

Previous appeals failed

  • Supplemental claims denied multiple times
  • Higher-Level Review unsuccessful
  • Need fresh eyes at highest level

You have time to wait

  • 12-36 months average timeline
  • Worth it for complex cases
  • Final VA decision (can only appeal to Court after this)

Three Board Appeal Lanes

Direct Review (Fastest)

  • No hearing, no new evidence
  • Judge reviews existing file only
  • Average: 12-15 months
  • Best for clear-cut cases where evidence is strong

Evidence Submission (Middle)

  • Can submit new evidence (90 days to submit)
  • No hearing
  • Average: 18-24 months
  • Best when you have new evidence but don't need hearing

Hearing Request (Slowest but Most Thorough)

  • Can submit new evidence
  • AND present case to judge in person or video
  • Average: 24-36+ months
  • Best for complex cases needing explanation

How to File a Board Appeal

Step 1: Decide Which Lane

  • Direct: Have strong file, no new evidence, want faster decision
  • Evidence: Have new evidence but don't need hearing
  • Hearing: Complex case, want to explain in person

Step 2: Complete VA Form 10182

  • Notice of Disagreement (Board Appeal)
  • Select your lane (Direct/Evidence/Hearing)
  • List issues you're appealing
  • Can appeal some issues, not others

Step 3: Submit Within 1 Year

  • Must file within 1 year of decision
  • File online at VA.gov or mail
  • Keep confirmation of filing

Step 4: If Evidence Lane - Submit Evidence

  • Have 90 days after filing to submit
  • Upload to VA.gov
  • Evidence must be new (not previously submitted)

Step 5: If Hearing Lane - Prepare for Hearing

  • Hearing scheduled months later
  • Choose: In-person (Regional Office), Video conference, or Central Office
  • Can submit evidence up to 90 days before hearing
  • Prepare opening statement and answers to likely questions

What to Expect at a Board Hearing

Format:

  • You, the judge, and your representative (if any)
  • Recorded hearing (transcript created)
  • 30-60 minutes typically
  • Informal but respectful

What the Judge Will Ask:

  • Background on your military service
  • When/how disability occurred or worsened
  • How disability affects daily life
  • Why you disagree with previous decision

What You Should Do:

  • Be honest and specific
  • Bring organized evidence (extra copies)
  • Explain worst days, not best days
  • Answer questions directly
  • Stay calm and respectful

What You Can Bring:

  • Witnesses (spouse, buddy who served with you)
  • Medical expert (if willing to attend)
  • Representative (VSO, attorney, agent)
  • Additional evidence not in file

Pro Tip: Hearings significantly improve success rates. Judges can ask clarifying questions and get a fuller picture of your case. If your case is complex or you're good at explaining yourself, request a hearing.

Board Appeal Timeline

LaneAverage ProcessingTypical Range
Direct Review12 months9-18 months
Evidence Submission20 months15-30 months
Hearing Request30 months24-48 months

Timelines vary by complexity and regional office

Gathering Winning Evidence for Your Appeal

Regardless of which appeal pathway you choose, strong evidence is critical.

Medical Evidence Best Practices

1. Current Diagnosis

  • Must be from qualified medical professional
  • Clearly states the diagnosis
  • Dated recently (within last year preferred)
  • On provider letterhead with credentials

2. Nexus Letter (For Service Connection or Secondary Conditions)

Must Include:

  • "It is at least as likely as not (probability of 50% or greater) that..."
  • Link between service/primary condition and current condition
  • Medical rationale explaining connection
  • Review of service treatment records, medical history
  • Provider credentials and signature

Example Nexus Statement:

"Based on my examination of the veteran, review of service treatment records showing right knee injury in 2015, and current diagnosis of left knee osteoarthritis, it is at least as likely as not that the veteran's left knee osteoarthritis is secondary to the service-connected right knee injury, which caused altered gait mechanics and abnormal stress on the left knee joint."

3. Severity Documentation

  • Treatment records showing ongoing care
  • Frequency of flare-ups documented
  • Medication lists (shows severity)
  • Specialist referrals
  • Hospital/ER visits
  • Imaging studies (X-rays, MRIs)
  • Physical therapy records

Lay Evidence Best Practices

Personal Statement Should Include:

  • When symptoms started (date/timeline)
  • How you know it's service-connected
  • Specific examples of functional limitations
  • Impact on work, relationships, daily activities
  • Worsening over time
  • Treatment sought

Buddy Statements Should Include:

  • Relationship to you (spouse, fellow service member, coworker)
  • How long they've known you
  • What they've personally observed
  • Before/after comparisons
  • Specific incidents or examples
  • How disability affects you

Effective Buddy Statement Example:

"I am John Smith's spouse of 20 years. Since his deployment to Iraq in 2005, I have personally witnessed his severe nightmares, hypervigilance, and avoidance of crowds. Before deployment, he was social and outgoing. Now he refuses family gatherings, can't sleep without medication, and becomes agitated in public. These changes began immediately after he returned from Iraq in 2006."

Service Connection Evidence

For Direct Service Connection:

  • Service treatment records (STRs) showing injury/illness
  • Buddy statements from fellow service members
  • Unit records, deployment orders
  • Personnel file showing MOS, duties
  • Pictures/documents from service

For Presumptive Conditions:

  • DD-214 showing service dates
  • Deployment records to qualifying location
  • Current diagnosis of presumptive condition
  • No other evidence needed if within presumptive period

For Secondary Connection:

  • Primary condition rating decision
  • Nexus letter linking primary to secondary
  • Medical literature supporting connection
  • Treatment records mentioning connection

Common Appeal Mistakes to Avoid

Mistake #1: Missing the 1-Year Deadline

Problem: If you don't appeal within 1 year of decision, you lose the ability to restore your original effective date.

Solution:

  • File Intent to File if you need more time
  • Calendar the 1-year deadline immediately
  • File appeal even if evidence isn't perfect yet

Mistake #2: Resubmitting Same Evidence

Problem: Supplemental claims require NEW evidence. Repeating what VA already reviewed gets denied.

Solution:

  • Review your C-file to see what VA had
  • Only submit truly new medical records, letters, statements
  • If no new evidence available, use Higher-Level Review instead

Mistake #3: Choosing Wrong Appeal Pathway

Problem: Filing Higher-Level Review when you have new evidence, or Supplemental Claim when VA made clear error.

Solution:

  • Use decision tree above
  • Consult with VSO or attorney
  • Can switch pathways if you realize you chose wrong

Mistake #4: Weak Nexus Language

Problem: Doctor writes "may be related" or "could be connected"—not strong enough.

Solution:

  • Request language: "at least as likely as not" (50%+ probability)
  • Provide doctor with template language
  • If doctor won't use strong language, seek different opinion

Mistake #5: Giving Up After One Denial

Problem: Assuming first denial is final.

Reality:

  • Most successful claims take 2-3 attempts
  • Appeals succeed 40-50% of the time
  • New evidence often changes outcome

Solution:

  • File supplemental claim with stronger evidence
  • Appeal to Board if necessary
  • Seek professional help if multiple denials

Mistake #6: Not Using Duty to Assist

Problem: Trying to find all evidence yourself.

Solution:

  • VA has duty to help you get evidence (STRs, VA medical records)
  • Request VA obtain service treatment records
  • Request VA medical opinions when nexus is needed
  • File formal request for assistance

Mistake #7: Informal Conference Mistakes (HLR)

Problem: Not requesting conference, or being unprepared for it.

Solution:

  • Always request conference (improves success rate)
  • Prepare specific page numbers referencing evidence
  • Practice explaining error concisely
  • Focus on facts, not emotions

When to Get Professional Help

Consider Hiring an Accredited Representative If:

Your claim has been denied multiple times

  • 2+ denials suggest need for expert help
  • Pattern indicates strategic issue

You have a complex service connection issue

  • Unusual circumstances
  • Conflicting medical evidence
  • Rare condition or presumptive issue

You need help gathering evidence

  • Don't know what evidence is needed
  • Can't afford private medical exams
  • Need nexus letters but doctors unwilling

You're appealing to the Board

  • Legal expertise valuable at this level
  • Hearing preparation critical
  • High stakes (final VA decision)

You qualify for TDIU

  • Complex employability arguments
  • Vocational evidence needed
  • High financial value ($24,000+/year)

Types of Representatives

Veterans Service Organizations (VSOs):

  • Free representation
  • Accredited representatives
  • Examples: DAV, VFW, American Legion, AMVETS
  • Experienced with common claims
  • Best for straightforward appeals

VA-Accredited Attorneys:

  • Can charge fees (typically 20-33% of back pay)
  • Only paid if you win
  • Specialized VA disability law expertise
  • Best for complex appeals, Board hearings, Court appeals
  • Required for appeals to U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims

VA-Accredited Claims Agents:

  • Can charge fees (similar to attorneys)
  • Often former VA employees
  • Experienced with VA processes
  • Best for moderately complex claims
Need a partner?

Need Help With Your Appeal?

Our VA-accredited claims strategists have a 90%+ success rate on appeals. We'll review your denial, identify the issues, and build a winning appeal strategy.

10,000+

Claims filed

95%

Success rate

24/7

Support

✓ No upfront costs • ✓ Veteran-owned & operated

Calculating What's at Stake: Back Pay from Appeals

Understanding potential back pay helps you decide how much effort to invest in your appeal.

Back Pay Restoration Rules

Supplemental Claim:

  • Restores original effective date if successful
  • Back pay from original claim date to new decision
  • Can be substantial (12-36 months typical)

Higher-Level Review:

  • Restores original effective date if successful
  • Same back pay calculation as supplemental claim

Board Appeal:

  • Restores original effective date if successful
  • Back pay can be 2-5 years (due to processing time)
  • Six-figure back pay possible for long-pending appeals

Back Pay Examples

Example 1: Supplemental Claim Success

  • Original claim: January 2023 (denied)
  • Supplemental claim filed: December 2023 (with new nexus letter)
  • Approved: June 2024 at 70%
  • Effective date: January 2023 (original claim)
  • Back pay period: 18 months
  • Monthly rate: $1,778.43 (70%, veteran alone)
  • Back pay: $1,778.43 × 18 = $32,011.74

Example 2: Board Appeal Success

  • Original claim: January 2020 (denied)
  • Supplemental claim: January 2021 (denied again)
  • Board appeal filed: January 2022
  • Approved: January 2025 at 100% TDIU
  • Effective date: January 2020 (original claim)
  • Back pay period: 60 months
  • Back pay (with COLA): ~$200,000+

Use our Back Pay Calculator to estimate what your appeal could be worth.

Appeal Success Strategies

Strategy 1: Target the Specific Denial Reason

Read the decision letter carefully:

  • Note exact reason for denial
  • Identify which evidence was missing
  • Gather evidence addressing that specific gap

Example:

  • Denial reason: "No current diagnosis"
  • Solution: Get diagnosed by doctor, submit updated medical records
  • Don't waste time gathering service records if that wasn't the issue

Strategy 2: Layer Your Evidence

Don't rely on single piece of evidence:

  • Medical records + nexus letter + buddy statements
  • Multiple doctors corroborating condition
  • Various types of evidence (lay + medical + service)

Why Layering Works:

  • Harder for VA to deny multiple sources
  • Shows pattern/consistency
  • Addresses multiple potential weaknesses

Strategy 3: Use Ratings Calculator to Verify

Before appealing rating percentage:

  • Use VA Disability Calculator to verify combined rating
  • Check if bilateral factor was applied
  • Ensure no calculation errors
  • Calculate what rating SHOULD be with correct math

If math is wrong:

  • Higher-Level Review is fastest fix
  • Point to specific calculation error
  • Reference VA's own combined ratings table

Strategy 4: Claim Secondary Conditions

If primary denied, consider secondary approach:

  • Can't prove direct service connection for knee?
  • Claim as secondary to back condition
  • Different path, often easier nexus

Use our Secondary Conditions Finder to identify alternatives.

Strategy 5: File Multiple Appeals for Different Issues

You can appeal different decisions simultaneously:

  • Supplemental claim for condition with new evidence
  • Higher-Level Review for miscalculated rating
  • Board appeal for complex PTSD claim

Each issue can use different pathway:

  • Optimize strategy for each condition
  • Maximize overall success rate

After Your Appeal Is Approved

What Happens Next

1. Decision Letter Arrives

  • Explains approval and new rating
  • States effective date
  • Shows monthly payment amount
  • Indicates back pay owed

2. Back Pay Processed

  • Typically 15-30 days after decision
  • Lump sum direct deposit
  • Labeled as "COMP & PEN"
  • Tax-free

3. Monthly Payments Begin

  • First regular payment next month
  • Direct deposit on 1st of each month
  • Based on effective date (may be prorated first month)

4. VA Healthcare Updates

  • Priority group may change
  • Medication copays may be waived
  • Additional benefits may unlock

Protecting Your New Rating

Be aware of rating reductions:

  • VA can reduce ratings in future reexaminations
  • Usually not for 5-10 years minimum
  • Permanent & Total (P&T) protections stronger

File for increases promptly:

  • If condition worsens, file for increase within 1 year
  • Continuous pursuit doctrine protects effective date
  • Don't wait—file as soon as condition worsens

Consider Additional Benefits:

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do I have to appeal a VA decision?

1 year from the decision date. If you miss this deadline, you can still file a new claim, but you lose the original effective date and potential back pay.

Can I work on my claim while it's being appealed?

Yes. You can gather additional evidence, see doctors, and prepare your case throughout the appeal process. For Supplemental Claims and Board Evidence Lane, you can submit new evidence during the process.

What if I disagree with my appeal decision?

After Supplemental Claim or HLR: File another appeal (can choose different pathway) After Board Appeal: Appeal to U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (requires attorney)

Can I withdraw my appeal?

Yes, at any time before a decision is made. You might withdraw to file a different type of appeal or to gather more evidence first.

Do I need an attorney for appeals?

Not required, but recommended for Board appeals and complex cases. VSOs provide free representation for most appeals. Attorneys typically needed only for Court appeals.

Will appealing affect my current benefits?

No. Your current rating and payments continue unchanged while your appeal is pending. If approved, you get an increase plus back pay. If denied, nothing changes.

Can I appeal just part of my decision?

Yes. You can appeal the rating for one condition while accepting the ratings for others. You can also appeal the effective date without challenging the rating percentage.

How do I check my appeal status?

Log into VA.gov → Claims & Appeals → Track Your Claims. You'll see current status, any requests from VA, and estimated completion date.

Tools and Resources

  • VA Disability Calculator: Verify your combined rating calculation
  • Secondary Conditions Finder: Identify alternative claim strategies
  • Back Pay Calculator: Calculate what your appeal is worth
  • TDIU Checker: See if you qualify for 100% unemployability
  • VA Forms:
    • VA Form 20-0995 (Supplemental Claim)
    • VA Form 20-0996 (Higher-Level Review)
    • VA Form 10182 (Board Appeal)
  • Decision Review Officer: Call 1-800-827-1000
  • Board of Veterans' Appeals: 1-800-923-8387

Final Thoughts

A VA disability claim denial is not the end—it's often just the beginning of a process that ends in approval for veterans who persist with proper evidence and strategy. With 50%+ success rates on appeals and the potential for tens of thousands of dollars in back pay, appealing a denied claim is almost always worth the effort.

Key Takeaways:

  • ✅ 70% of initial claims denied, but 50%+ of appeals succeed
  • ✅ Three pathways: Supplemental Claim (new evidence), Higher-Level Review (VA error), Board Appeal (complex cases)
  • ✅ Supplemental Claims fastest with new evidence (4-6 months)
  • ✅ Higher-Level Review best for clear errors (4-6 months)
  • ✅ Board Appeals most thorough but slowest (12-36 months)
  • ✅ Successful appeals restore original effective date (max back pay)
  • ✅ Strong nexus letters critical for service connection
  • ✅ You have 1 year to appeal from decision date
  • ✅ Can switch appeal pathways if first attempt fails
  • ✅ Professional representation improves success rates

Don't give up on benefits you've earned. Appeal with the right strategy and evidence.


Related Articles:

Get Help With Your Appeal - Free Initial Consultation Our VA-accredited claims strategists can review your denial and recommend the best appeal strategy.

Related Articles

Need guidance?

Get Expert Help Building Your Claim

Book time with a VetClaims.ai strategist for hands-on help building your claim package so you can move forward with confidence.

  • Fast-track filing with expert prep
  • Personalized evidence roadmap tailored to your claim

Want to talk to someone first? Call (737) 344-4399 for immediate help.